We have this rule, the no free items no free money rule, in order to keep things a little more fair and balanced. If some of the more experienced and rich players started throwing out expensive items anytime someone said they wanted them we would have a corrupt economy. Since we do not want to wipe the economy we have this rule. I hope this helps make a little more sense of it. Also I think it is really nice of players to let each other know before someone break a rule and is punished for it.
Everyone has bad days and an apology has been made and therefore this thread is resolved and shall be locked. If you are unhappy with the resolution here do not hesitate to either PM me in game or on the website. Thanks